Sunday, December 31, 2006

a list, part 1: super-awesome, highly recommended books about those old guys in u2

what the heck are you going to do with all those piles of money lying in front of you as the new year begins? (um, buy books?)

music and books. dork it up a little, people. some of my mensa-level blogging friends have helped me come up with a list of some great music-related books. yeah, um, but that list isn't coming until part 2.

first, this is part 1: and it's all about the u2. there are lots of bad u2 books out there people. a lot. i'm sure there are a few good ones that are missing from my list, as well. (do tell!)

these are the u2 books on my recommendation list:

U2 by U2,
by U2 with Neil McCormick

2005
the "full" story, as told by the band and manager paul mcguinness. quite weighty, with lots of photos of cute boys in the band.

some say u2 thinks too highly of themselves. i say "is that even possible?" in this book, the boys say they can't play their instruments, can't sing, can't write songs, and on, and on. their criticisms of their own songs in this book had me screaming at the book. (really). they think in god's country is no good for f*ck's sake! edge can't remember how he made certain sounds come out of his guitar and so he can't play when i look at the world live!? mcguinness with the no bullshit comments about certain tensions between the band and brian eno? revelation. baby larry almost getting kicked out of baby u2 for having a real job? whaaat!? but perhaps my favorite aspect of this book is bono's framing of his own life story with adam clayton playing the part of bono's conscience in love. a book packed with inane details best appreciated by psychos like us ardent fans.

Unforgettable Fire,
by Eamon Dunphy

1987
an authorized biography that u2 was pissed off about, the details in it were gathered over an eighteen-month period during which the author lived and traveled with the band members (but didn't let them read the book before he published it).

a lot of people avoid this book because it is an "unauthorized" authorized biography. it does contain a few (irrelevant) factual mistakes, but this two-decade-old book's analysis of certain things - bono and his dad's relationship, for one, is right on. there is some stuff in here that is partly based on rumor and innuendo, but when taken with a grain of salt, i think it offers an honest view of what people in the dublin scene around the band thought of them in the 80s - i.e., this is not just what they wanted to reveal of themselves. (please don't tell larry i recommended this!)

Bono in Conversation with Michka Assayas,
by Michka Assayas

2005
bono is seriously not stupid. he's also funny, acerbic and genuinely hot humble.

read it and you will agree. really. this is a whole book of bono Q&A. when this first came out, i thought it was the best thing ever. bono reveals personal stories, particularly about his childhood with his father and brother, and he explains and details his faith in a way that he never had before. in the 2+ years since it came out, many of these things have been rehashed and repeated, but i still think this is a fresh and fascinating read.

Killing Bono: I Was Bono's Doppelganger,
by Neil McCormick

2004
the author of this memoir went to school with the band and stayed friends with bono, and this funny and revealing story details the author's quest to emulate the success of the bono. imagine that.

this book is definitely not "about" bono, but it includes some priceless early days details. teenage u2 practicing the "batman" theme song in a school classroom - with our hero jumping off a school desk and yelling "batman!" to punctuate the tune's ending? that might be my favorite part. it offers a fly-on-the-wall look at some other early u2 moments, but the book is really about neil's lifelong desire to be his own rock star. it details his inner turmoil at watching bono the "good boy" become the rock star that neil's inner bad boy always wanted to be. and more than anything else i have ever read about bono, this book validated my obsession. neil's memoir humanizes bono, peels away his outer shell, and reveals him to be, at his core, someone quite heroic. it is a funny book, written with heavy doses of cynicism.

U2, The Best of Propaganda,
by Ian Gittins

2003
propaganda was the official U2 fan-club magazine from the early 80s up to 2000, and this is an anthology of sorts.

there are some gems of old interviews and fan recollections (early days concert reviews and encounters with the band) as well as a multitude of through-the-years quotes in which you can see u2 contradicting themselves, going full circle, and throwing shapes like nobody's business. it is because of an edge interview in propaganda that i own a book called "the man who mistook his wife for a hat." really. i think particularly for fans who were not yet obsessed (alive??) in the 80s, this is a must-have.

Walk On, The Spiritual Journey of U2,
by Steve Stockman

2001 / 2005 (reissue)
a book that attempts to explain the "dichotomy" that lies at the heart of u2 - rock 'n' roll and God.

this is a good introduction to u2's faith, and how it is revealed in their art. there are some broad generalizations, simplifications and assumptions in this book that i disagree with, but as a whole, the book opened my eyes. it put me on a path to be way more open to faith-based analysis of u2's work. (sometimes it's hard to remember that just a few years ago bono really was way more cagey about making public statements about his faith.) as with any genre, there are plenty of "u2 & religion" books out there written by people who you can tell just do not "get" the band, but this is not one of them. rather, this one helped me "get" certain things about the band a bit more. it is not my belief that you need to share the same faith as u2 in order to explore it.

U2 At The End of the World,
by Bill Flanagan

1996
flanagan is a great writer and a trusted friend of the band and the access he had for this book - public and private lives - makes for a very revealing read. this is an authorized biography that covers a 3-year period in the 90s.

some fans have "biblical" feelings for this book. it is a snapshot of a very short period in the band's career (zoo tv era). it reveals a side of the band that is very different from the one they currently present to the world. it is fun and even a little risque, and has lots of episodes where bono leads you right to the edge of the abyss leaving the reader to decide if he ever falls in. (jumps in?) but my absolute favorite parts of this book are bill flanagan's conversations with bono's father bob hewson. "your mother Christened you paul, and paul you're going to remain!" this book is very entertaining and very well-written. it is also basically centered around bono's idea of what the zoo tv era was about. intriguing and very open to misinterpretation.

okay, that's my u2 book list. what's on yours?

related:
part 2: the best rock bios
part 3: music-related books that heather likes
part 4: dr. bob k's list focuses on the beatles


~ happy new year!

13 Comments:

Blogger Honey said...

Wow. Nice list. I can't believe you read all those books about U2. You must be, like...a huge fan or something.

11:16 AM  
Anonymous U2 Nerd said...

I can't believe you don't have "U2 Live: A Concert Documentary" by Pimm Jal de la Parra on the list. For hardcore U2 fans -- as well as the band themselves and their crew -- it's an indispensable resource.

12:36 PM  
Blogger blue kite said...

Great review. Couldn“t agree more!

1:49 PM  
Anonymous Jason said...

I agree with U2 Nerd. U2 Live should be on the list. Also, Race of Angels The Genesis of U2 by John Waters is very interesting. It dissects U2 from an Irish cultural perspective. I haven't finished U2 by U2 but i think it could have been organized better.

4:58 PM  
Blogger *melinda* said...

for christmas i got U2 by U2....TWICE! i wanna start reading it soon....

on the batman subject: the edge played the theme for the newest batman series i think in 04. for the first couple of seasons they kept it but as soon as bat girl came on they changed the whole song and it's crapy. so he professionally got to play the theme, except this time it was edgy and dark.

book: "A Grand Madness: 10 Years on the Road With U2". I think i've mentioned this one before 2 u, but it's really good and it brings new meaning on the terms "fan" and "obsessed".

happy new year!*

9:42 PM  
Blogger Molly said...

I'd add U2 Show by Diana Scrimgeour (sp?), lots of awesome photos and behind-the-scenes info from the early days through Elevation.

I recently got a used copy of Outside is America: U2 in America, I'll let you know how it is!

I have yet to read Flanagan's book which is referred to as "the u2 bible" by a lot of fans. I need to get that one of these days!!!

11:06 PM  
Blogger U2Lorax said...

I own U2 by U2 & have perused the Best of Propaganda thanks to the local library. Love the former, the latter got on my nerves with all the "natch"s. I think that's the word the writer used every other sentence.

I've been told by several peeps to locate a copy of Three Chords & The Truth by Niall Stokes. However, since it's out of print that's been a tad difficult.

5:54 PM  
Blogger moe "simon metz" berg said...

the flanagan book is absolutely unreal. i can take it down from the shelf, open to a random page and kill and hour or two every few months.

1:35 AM  
Blogger Nastyboy said...

Read 'em all.

I also like One Step Closer: Why U2 Matters to Those Seeking God. by Christian Scharen, and U2: Into the Heart by Niall Stokes.

2:45 AM  
Anonymous jethronh said...

i have a little short book called U2 the early days thats pretty cool. if you're into the preboy/boy era.... it's great! full of photos and tidbits...

but, i agree with U2 nerd...U2 Live: A Concert Documentary" by Pimm Jal de la Parra is THE book of U2 Books!!!! my wife got me the updated version for xmas. my favorite gift!!!!


jeff

1:52 PM  
Blogger c said...

i was just clicking through the atu2 fan survey, and lo and behold: here are the favorite u2 books results....

thanks for all the comments/recommendations, peeps ;)

3:53 PM  
Anonymous sirensong said...

Great list! Just finished U2 by U2. It's hard to put down! I think my arms are in the best shape they've ever been in - That is one heavy book! Loved Michka Assayas' book. Can't wait to check into the others.

Happy New Year Ya'll!

5:01 PM  
Anonymous Gibigiane said...

I'd like to second John Water's Race of Angels: The Genesis of U2!

3:09 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home